>blink D.G. Voice

EHRC's Disability Committee: end in sight for influencing legislation

Jul 30, 2013

Fears about the future of disability rights have continued to be raised in the light of the Equality and Human Rights Commission's plan

Fears about the future of disability rights have continued to be raised in the light of the Equality and Human Rights Commission's plan to disband it's statutory body, the Disability Committee.


The proposal to replace the statutory body with an advisory one with no legal powers to make decisions on disability-related matters, follows an independent review carried out by disabled activist and former member of the Disability rights Committee Agnes Fletcher which recommended retaining the statutory status of the Disability Committee for another four years. Retaining its status, according to Fletcher, would have provided disabled people with the confidence that rights were being safeguarded at the highest level.


The minister for disabled people Esther McVey suggested to Disability Now last week that the Disability Committee lacked teeth.


But Mike Smith, (pictured) who was the committee's chair until December 2012, told Disability Now that he disagreed and that he suspected that the future of the Disability Committee had been decided before Fletcher's review.


He said that it was the environment that the Disability Committee had been operating in which had constrained it.


'The Equality Act 2006 which set up the committee, gave it quite far-reaching powers, so it certainly doesn't lack teeth. What it may have lacked is the full support of the whole commission, which meant that it wasn't able to do as much as it wanted to. I think in the very early days of the commission, there was a strong focus from the commission on not doing single quality strand work but on doing stuff that could apply to groups of people and therefore the Disability Committee was restricted in what it was able or allowed to do - there was a fear that if we had communicated more with disability stakeholders, other strands would have asked for the same. In later years, with down-sizing, we were told that there were less resources available. It wasn’t for lack of trying.'


He added: 'An advisory body may well have good influence and it may reach out further, but it does have to be said that there were times in the past when the Disability Committee over-ruled the decisions of commission staff on really important cases like RBS against Allen [relating to RBS's legal obligation to provide wheelchair access to its banks], and the Cordell case [relating to central government failing to meet the support needs of a deaf employee]. Initially, the commission staff didn't perceive the strategic importance of those cases and it was the Disability Committee and me as disability commissioner that were able to drive through the change in the response to that. It is questionable whether an advisory committee could have the same influence without the backup of those statutory powers.'


A current member of the Disability Committee who did not want to be named, said that a new advisory body would be ignored by the commission.


The committee member said: 'The Disability Committee was the last vestige of the regulatory aspect of the EHRC which is gradually being turned into a let's-trust-everybody-to-do-the-right-thing body which is all very well if organisations could be trusted to do the right thing. In my opinion, they can't be which is why the EHRC is there.'


Asked what the EHRC's motives in abolishing the Disability Committee might be, the committee member said: 'I suspect that the commission think that every commissioner should be looking at all strands equally. In fact disability can be distinctly different in that you can treat everybody equally, but if you don't remove the barriers that stop people being equal... it's not about how you feel about somebody but it's about whether they can get on a bus for instance.'


Fletcher said that she was disappointed with the EHRC's stance and added: “I welcome the Commission’s commitment to continue to have a group of high-level experts on disability to help steer its work in this crucial area but believe that to be meaningful the Commission must guarantee that there will be sufficient money and people for the next three to four years to enable a suitably strategic input into the Commission’s decision-making process; the Commission’s CEO (or Deputy) will be responsible for ensuring the non-statutory committee’s work is given equal strategic prominence throughout the Commission’s workplan; there is a transparent process for recruiting disabled people to any replacement body; and that sufficient resource and commitment is given to direct, face to face engagement with disabled people’s organisations around Britain.'


Disability Now

Midsteeple, High Street
Dumfries DG1 2BH
t: 01387 257770
e: info@dgvoice.co.uk

Current News

 
 

News Archive

 

Press Release

DGVoice, the Voice of disabled people in Dumfries and Galloway, have written to the Health Board.

Read more... »

Universal Credit 'plagued by problems', says director

Universal Credit 'plagued by problems', says director

The remarks are the most outspoken yet from within government, admitting that the introduction of Universal Credit — the flagship project of Iain Duncan Smith, the Work and Pensions Secretary — has been undermined by technical and bureaucratic problems and is behind schedule.

Read more... »

£1.4m to reduce benefit cuts pain

COUNCILS across the south of Scotland have been given extra funding to help housing benefit claimants affected by the so-called “bedroom tax”.

Read more... »

Life doesn't end with amputation

A man who had to have a leg cut off to save his life wants to set up a support group for fellow amputees.

Read more... »

Accessible tourism scheme to generate £325m for Scotland

Accessible tourism scheme to generate £325m for Scotland

Making tourist services more accessible to disabled people, young children and elderly people could generate £325 million a year

Read more... »

Chris Hallam

Chris Hallam

Chris Hallam, who has died aged 49, was a hero of the Paralympic movement who won medals in both wheelchair racing and swimming;

Read more... »

Is it too difficult for disabled people to find volunteering roles?

Is it too difficult for disabled people to find volunteering roles?

Many disabled people are experiencing a surprising level of difficulty in finding volunteering roles.

Read more... »

Dismay over treatment of some elderly people in Scottish hospitals.

Dismay over treatment of some elderly people in Scottish hospitals.

It was with some dismay I read Healthcare Improvement Scotland's audit of care of older people in acute hospitals.

Read more... »

Disabled wife saw husband killed in Asda parking space row - and he had blue badge for her

Disabled wife saw husband killed in Asda parking space row - and he had blue badge for her

Christine Holmes watched helplessly as carer Brian was attacked in a ­Bedfordshire supermarket car park

Read more... »

DGVoice Expresses Fears on Blue Badge Delays

DGVoice Expresses Fears on Blue Badge Delays

Call for 10-week renewal timescale to be cut

Read more... »

Disabled teenager left distraught

Disabled teenager left distraught

NINO ZAVARONI, who suffers from cerebral palsy, was stunned when the ScotRail worker refused to set up the ramp for him - despite standing right next to one.

Read more... »

Benefit test firm under attack by Scots minister

Benefit test firm under attack by Scots minister

Housing and welfare minister Margaret Burgess has written to the French multinational outlining concerns

Read more... »

EHRC's Disability Committee: end in sight for influencing legislation

Fears about the future of disability rights have continued to be raised in the light of the Equality and Human Rights Commission's plan

Read more... »

Watchdog warns elderly care still not good enough

CONTINUING shortcomings in elderly care have been highlighted by Scotland's hospital watchdog

Read more... »

Atos: PM orders end 
to company's monopoly of benefits health tests

Atos: PM orders end 
to company's monopoly of benefits health tests

David Cameron has ordered an end 
to the monopoly enjoyed by the company operating the controversial fitness-to-work tests amid fears too many of its assessments were flawed.

Read more... »

Scots team leads new treatment to repair MS damage

Scots team leads new treatment to repair MS damage

NEW treatments to repair the damage in the brain caused by multiple sclerosis (MS) could now be developed thanks to Scottish research.

Read more... »

Brain injury man wants to give something back

A Dumfries man who suffered a serious head injury in a car crash is taking to the road on his bike to raise charity cash.

Read more... »

Keys to making life easier for Scotland's learning disabled

WHEN you revisit a revolution, you can be on a hiding to nothing.

Read more... »

Billions in benefits go unclaimed, DWP figures show

Billions in benefits go unclaimed, DWP figures show

Benefits worth billions of pounds - ranging from pension credit to jobseeker's allowance - go unclaimed each year, figures show.

Read more... »

Sick and disabled people 'to lose £1bn in benefit cash'

Sick and disabled people are facing a "quadruple whammy" from the UK Government's welfare reforms, a leading advice charity has said.

Read more... »

GPs not ‘supporting’ Atos disabled patients

Tuesday, 11 June 2013

GPs will be seen as “lacking compassion” over their refusal to provide support letters for disabled patients who face losing benefits as a result of the overhaul of the welfare system, MSPs warned today.


Read more... »

PIP

Personal Independence Payment

On 8 April 2013 the Government introduced a new benefit called Personal Independence Payment (PIP) to replace Disability Living Allowance (DLA) for eligible working age people aged 16 to 64.


Read more... »